Tuesday, June 10, 2014

Assembling the Frames

Laser level aligned with the center of the Strongback
With all frames complete we are ready to start assembling them on the Strongback and excited to start seeing the form of the vessel take shape.  As was mentioned during the Strongback construction, we used a Bosch crossbeam laser level to establish the centerline and horizontal plane.  Before starting, this was checked again and looked to be within 1/16" or so along its length. Plenty close enough for a material that shrinks and swells with temperature and humidity anyway.
Initially I was going to use the string shown in the photo (illuminated by he laser) as a guide to align the center of the frames but thought it would be a great idea to use the laser instead.  It proved to work well with a few practical considerations: 1. Start from the furthest frame and work toward the laser so as not to create a shadow from a frame set in front of another and 2. get these set in one day because it was tedious to realign the vertical plumb on the level.  Even turning the switch on and off will knock it out of alignment.
With that said we proceeded from Station 20 at the back and worked forward.  For this portion my Father was there to help as this is a two person job trying to steady the frames and screw them in place (temporarily) at the right height.
Using the plan below...

Top View of Strongback with station measurements along the top of the drawing

We laid out the stations on the horizontal deck of the Strongback on both sides and checked the diagonal on the first set of marks to be sure that we were square to the centerline.  Within 1/16" so I was happy. Now, let me stop for a second and explain myself.  I am not by nature extremely anal about such things.  I don't mention "diagonals with 1/16" to show out or "top the knob".  What I have learned over the years is that if you can get the foundation of anything as nearly perfect as possible, then you will find the rest of the project falling into place if you take reasonable care.  What can kill a project and turn it into an exercise in tedium is to have something a little un-square or un-level and then fight it with ever cut and corner from then on out. 
Station 20 Frame clamped and ready to screw into 2" x 3" horizontal support
Okay, with that said we started setting the frames. Remember that this is built upside down at this point.  What you see to the left is the first frame (Station 20) clamped off at the proper height measured from the deck of the Strongback. The horizontal member that the frame is clamped to is screwed in place to the Strongback. The ends will be sawn off flush when done.









To the right you see me screwing in the horizontal member before setting the next frame.  Now that we had established a proper height based off of the plans from the deck of the Strongback to the top of the upside down frame, it is time to center this using the laser's vertical plumb line.


Pencil center mark sitting in the middle of projected laser line.

To accomplish this without constantly rechecking the height, we clamped a temporary board to the frame resting on the  horizontal cross member and simply slide it back and forth until centered.  Here is a view of what I'm talking about in sequence of construction...
  1. The C-clamp is holding the darker, horizontal board firmly to the frame maintaining the height of the frame. 
  2. The blue clamp is released and the frame is slide left to right to align the centers.
  3. Once centered, the blue clamp is reapplied to free the hands.
  4. The frame is screwed in its final position and everything unclamped... next.
This was continued from frame to frame and took about three hours total...

Completed up to Station #4
 I have to complete the transom and stem at this point and they will be a page to themselves.  Then its off to the chine installation, and then ready to skin with marine plywood.
 
BTW... 6/27/2014
For those checking the blog my ply is on backorder.  I have a road trip ahead of me and am anxious to get back on this. Stay tuned and I'll announce new updates when I finally have material.
Thanks...
 
UPDATE!!! 8/5/14
 
40 sheets of 1/2" and 6 sheeets of 1/4"... No problem.
The marine ply finally came in. I agonized over what to buy, weighing benefit vs. cost.  I finally decided on Roseburg Marine Grade AB Fir.  If I weren't covering every square inch of this ply in either epoxy coated fabric or a layer of decorative wood, I doubt this would have made much sense.  The Fir can be a pain to get a good level surface on when sanding as the darker and lighter grain is of two different desities and it's easy to hollow out the softer grain while leaving the harder grain proud and the surface wavy.   I ordered from Menards, a midwest building supply.  The closest store was in Owensboro, Kentucky but well worth the drive.  The savings compared to what I would have spent locally was significant at almost 35% once the gas to pick up was factored in. 
Next I start cutting this up and move along with the project...
 




Tuesday, June 3, 2014

Building the Frames... 6-10-2014 update added to bottom of post

Pine Stock planed to thickness
Stock:
We chose kiln dried, clear Yellow Pine to build the frames. Yellow Pine is a traditional boatbuilding wood and extremely durable, cheap too at $1.33 a board foot.  It's grown here in my state and makes sense to me.  4/4 stock was chosen over 8/4 because we intend to laminate the frames with half lap joints for assembly.  They will be glued and screwed together.  I plan to encapsulate both frames and hull with epoxy on the inside "overbuilding" with the use of fillets and fiberglass tape at the seams for added strength and water resistance if it did find its way down there.  I may change my mind on this point, however, it may be money well spent at least below the waterline.

Milling and Cutting:

We started with rough sawn clear 1" x 6" x 12's, my wife and I  milling them down to 3/4" final thickness, then ripped them down to a full 4" width. As cramped as my shop is it helped having my wife catch the boards on the off side as they were fed through on both the planer and the table saw.  This would be impossible to do myself on the jointer with its short bed.  We have done this so many times, with thousands of board feet of lumber under our collective belts that we didn't have to go over a game plan on how to separate the pieces as we made 6 to 8 planer passes, each being flipped each time.
Typical Frame - Station 6
The leftover strips will serve as cleats and scrap to be used as needed.  I made the decision to add the additional height to the bottom chord as needed to create a level sole ("boat speak" for floor). I thought its was easier to make them all 4" high instead of custom cutting a series of widths for each station.

Frames cut and stacked - awaiting assembly
I then proceeded to cut these to length slowly and methodically working my way through the prints as each cut was a slightly different angle, and was measured from either real or projected end points.  I stacked these into bundles so they wouldn't get mixed up (past learning experience paying off here) and taping them together for future assembly.


Assembly:

316 Stainless Shark Screws
I agonized (maybe not agonized) over the decision of what to use for both fasteners and glue for frame assembly.  Traditional choices would be silicon bronze fasteners and epoxy glue.  I understand the idea of using these fasteners and glues for boats that spend their lives in the water and will see themselves immersed for extended periods. The Redwing will not.  The reality is that she will spend most of her life on a trailer in a covered building and her bilges will be pumped or drained every time she is used.  This didn't mean that I was interested in using white Elmer's and sheet rock screws, but I did settle on different choices for several reasons. 
For glue, I settled on PL Premium by Loctite available at most big box stores.   I read through a lot of literature and suggestions by experienced builders and it shows great promise as a highly water resistant adhesive that exhibits great strength and bonding properties.  Its available in convenient caulk tubes, can be capped at night (I use a stubby screwdriver) and has low VOC's (fumes). I must be clamped extremely well as the foam out has no strength.  This was no problem as my fasteners would provide the clamping pressure needed.  Speaking of fasteners... I made the decision to stick with Stainless Screws in this application for a few reasons:
  1. Cost - about a third of what silicon bronze costs.
  2. Intention to fully encapsulate the frames.
  3. Use of 316 Stainless vs. 304 which is more resistant to saltwater chlorides, the real culprit with pitting and corrosion.
  4. Reasons mentioned above.
I ordered the screws (#8 x 1-1/2") from Manasquan fasteners and when they arrived was boxed by Simpson Strong Tie (marked as dock fasteners for saltwater).  They are a high-low thread which are purportedly harder to back out and they drove well.  Only available in Phillips drive I was worried that they would cam out but I had no such trouble.  They drove well without predrilling on all but the smallest of pieces.  I intend to use them when it comes time to attach the plywood to the frames, patching them with an epoxy and microballon slurry before covering with Xynole fabric and epoxy.

Ready for clamping (screwing) together
Assembly was pretty straight forward. I laid the pieces out to check for proper fit and alignment and had to trim a piece or two along the way. I would then just lay a generous pattern of  PL down  and using pencil marks drawn during the check for alignment, I would begin screwing the pieces together adjusting them along their length in pairs spaced 6" to 8" apart.  The squeeze out was satisfactory and I cleaned it up along the way with a putty knife and scrap board.  I kept everything I needed in a tote close at hand to limit the amount of time I spent hunting for tools and such.

Note the chine (corners) and limbered (horizontal) notches
Set aside to cure, I managed one frame per night. I would sand and clean up the previous night's frame and mark and cut the chine slots that will tie all frames together once secured on the Strongback.  I also "limbered" up the frames. In other words I used a hole saw to cut a half moon notch in the bottom center of each frame.  The purpose is to allow water that may find its way into the bilge a path to gravitate to the lowest point of the boat where I will mount an automatic bilge pump.  I will leave station 20 and 2 unlimbered so as to provide a solid bulkhead fore and aft.  I'll foam fill the forepeak below the anchor locker and mount a second bilge pump behind station 20 to handle any water that finds its way into that part of the boat.

6-10-2014 UPDATE...

The final few frames forward are a little different in their form and function. These are at Stations 2 and 4 at the very front or forepart of the boat. You can see how they narrow and grow taller toward the front as the hull curves up and in to the stem or sharp edge of the boat.
Frames 2 and 4 Construction Plans
They are different because the top part of the frame is a closed arc that forms the front deck of the boat ahead of the cabin or small projection with the round portholes in the picture on the "Concept and Design" page.
I had intended to get back to the lumber supplier for more pine to build the arched tops but hadn't had the chance and didn't want to waste a weekend.  I had some white oak sitting around from a past project and decided to use it as it is a very suitable boat building wood and is very strong.  I thought it may serve well here with the combined weight of the cabin resting on it, as well as, a crew member standing on it while working the anchor.
Template for Station 2 (half of arch) 
Here you see my marking the oak with a template that I made by plotting the arch full size, gluing to a cheap piece of Masonite hardboard and sawing out.  Paper stretches too much and is fairly fragile.  It won't hold up too long in a shop environment. I used a square to align the center line, then flipped it over to do the other side using the square flipped over as well.
Station 4 inside edge sawn
This was followed by cutting out the two part frames (overlapping butt joints like the rest of the frames) with a jigsaw.  I could have used a band saw with even better results but the jig saw answered well enough for this fairly small task on 4/4 stock. If I attempted anything thicker the bandsaw would have to be used because of the tendency for a jigsaw to veer at an angle when cutting a curve.  I did get a little of that but would sand them off together for an even edge.
Once cut I glued them up using Titebond III PVA adhesive and screwed them together to clamp and cure for 30 minutes or so. 

HANDY TIP ALERT #1

From the middle to the edge
One tip on gluing up and one I learned building saddles and it's a simple one... Always glue from the inside of the part to the edge, not from the edge to the middle. From the edge to the middle only scraps off the glue on the boards edge, however, brushing from the middle out will leave the glue sitting at the edge of the board. This saved me a lot of nasty leather edges which are as important to saddle making as tight joints are to woodworking.  Now, I'm not one for extreme neatness in glue ups and honestly am very generous with the glue.  I keep a bucket of warm water handy to immediately scrub and sponge and don't mind a healthy squeeze out along the edges. But I hate to "scrape" the brush off as I spread glue across the surfaces being coated.


Assembled Frame Deck Beam
Okay, back to assembly.  Here is the part screwed and glued and needing a wipe down. Wipe with lots of water. Glue left on the surface will prevent finish or subsequent glues from adhering. You won't hurt the wood I promise. You'll notice that the top board stops short the width of the overlapping frame portion.  Once they had set for a while I used an oscillating belt sander (present from my wife many years ago, Thank you Wife!) to dress the edges even and to take the variances in the two cuts. 
Assembled Station 4 Frame

















Stations #2 & #4
I then proceeded to assemble them using the PL Premium adhesive that was used on the other frames checking diagonals for squareness.  Limbered up and notched as the rest of them were was the final step and we were ready to start mounting these on the Strongback. Check that process out on "Setting the Frames" page. Thanks!




 



Monday, June 2, 2014

The Strongback

Still coming up to the present in my posting so here we are at the building of the strongback and frames...

Building Basics:

For everyone reading who is not familar with the method of construction I've chosen or boatbuilding in general, I'll briefly cover the basics of what this construction method consists of and why you need a Strongback (not a strong back, although it probably wouldn't hurt to have one of those too). Screw and Glue is basically building a rigid skeleton of frames spaced at pretermined distances (Stations). The Frames are also mounted at specific heights off of a base line to create a curve or Rocker to the hull if you view it from the side.
The frames are then covered with a layer of plywood and attached by screws and glue.  The hull is then covered with either a fiberglass or polyester cloth embedded in epoxy resin.  The purpose is to create an abrasion resistant layer. For this purpose I will use xynol, an abrasion resistant fabric that conforms to the curves well and is sort of a poor man's kevlar in its performance.  The hull is constructed upside down, finished out as far as possible, then flipped to be finished right side up.  That's about it for the basics.

Strongback:

 The Strongback (SB) is the framework of lumber that provides a flat, sturdy surface on which the frames are mounted upside down temporarily as the hull is constructed.  Here is a drawing of it with a figure added to create a sense of scale in the drawing.


You'll notice the Station numbers in 2' increments and the rocker I spoke of from front to back.  the figure is looking toward the back (Aft) or at the Transom.  The front (Fore) has a stem that creates the sharp front of the boat.

View Looking from the Transom - note yellow centerline string
The Strongback is built out of standard 2"X4" SPF lumber, nothing special but I did take care to pick out the straightest ones that HD had to offer.  I also used a combination of 2-1/2" and 1-5/8" pocket hole screws as they drive easy due to the square drive and cut tip.  I used scrap 1x material for bracing the upright ladders both fore and aft as well as athwart ships (side to side) once they were leveled.  I also used a Bosch laser level mounted on the wall at the end of the photo.  This I used to level the horizontal deck of the Strongback, the most important part of the assembly.  The bottom cleats are screwed to the floor. Note diagonal bracing as well.
Another view from the Stem. Strongback at Stations 4 and 2 are not assembled because the have a closed deck beam and have to be threaded on.

Getting Started...


Starting actual work:
I am catching up on progress thus far and will back track a little to speak of shop space and what we did to accomodate the construction of the RW23.
Converted Shop Space

Shop Space:
Boat shown in Silouette in shop space
Having reduced the horse population at our place from five to our present two geldings, I was left with quite a bit of usable, covered stall space that could be converted to shop space by simply closing it in.  The stalls were 12' x 18' and two of them sat adjacent to a 12' x 12' feed/storage room.  In essence this could provide 36' x 12'+ of usable space plus the additional 6' of width along 24' of that same room.  The stall floors were rubber mat covered so a proper floor was needed that could be used to screw down jigs and strongbacks.  We laid salvaged joists from the dismanteled stalls and decked them with 3/4" subfloor.  The ceiling was covered in 7/16" OSB decking and everything painted white before four 8' - T5 flourescent strips were installed to give a little over 119 lumens per square foot according to a Lithonia lighting online software program (thanks to Brad Wilkinson, our resident Engineering guru in the office).With that I laid out the space in CAD to be sure of headroom and to also make sure that the Redwing would fit due to an aggravating step up into the feed room (it having been constructed some years back at a different height). You can see its a tight fit in elevation but not too bad in plan view.

This will eventually require that the boat be removed through the end wall and some work probably will have to be accomplished outside.  It is my intention however to mount it on v-groove casters set on inverted angle iron that will extend beyond the shop on salvaged post and beams so that it can be rolled in and out as needed until complete.












Sunday, June 1, 2014

Concept and Design...

Redwing 18
The Redwing series of camp cruisers are the brainchild of Naval Architect Ken Stambaugh of Chesapeake Marine Design in Severna Park, Maryland. Based on a traditional Chapelle design, the popular Redwing 18 is a traditional displacement hull, micro-cruiser built of plywood in either traditional screw and glue or stitch and glue construction. 


Initially I moved toward this design as my basic requirements centered around a trailerable cruiser that would allow us to stay out on the water overnight.  Well as I mentioned we live within a six or so hour drive of the coast but not nearly close enough to run down for an overnighter. So it became apparent that we would need something larger that would let us stay out longer and make the trip worth our while.  Already liking the Redwing boats I began to peruse Ken's variants of the RW 18 and found a pilot house version that looked to be perfect.  It came in a 21' and 23' and provided the weather protection of the pilothouse and much roomier accommodations for a couple over a long week of exploring or a small group for a comfortable picnic. I settled on the 23' version of the Pilothouse and ordered plans last February. 


Original 23' by Ken Stambaugh
 
With plans in hand I used AutoCAD to loft the table of offsets.  The RW23 didn't come with many detailed plans but there was enough information contained within the RW21views to cad the various plans, elevations and section views and by April I had worked out the design and layout to the point where I knew I was ready to begin.  I had also decided on a Screw and glue method of construction because it seemed more traditional, flexible and would allow me to start on construction before purchasing plywood. Here is or was the initial version of the RW23 as I had drawn it...

Initial Version - Mine
Not so fast... During this period I would naturally come upon design questions that would prompt me to go out to the various boards and forums looking for answers.  I couldn't leave well enough alone and have only settled on a design in the past two weeks that is quite a metamorphosis from Ken's original design.
I'll explain...
I am not ashamed of a wooden boat being made from wood and love the old Elco Yachts from the 20's with their extensive brightwork and long canopies.  I couldn't take advantage of the distinctive break in the sheer as most of these do but could borrow heavily from the design details to create a Redwing variant.  I also noted through my frequent perusal of the various cruising and building sites that if I didn't whole heartily embrace the boxy look of a traditional gentleman's crusier I would have a hard time hiding the increased cabin height.  I also wanted to protect the cockpit with a full length roof/canopy from the hot summer sun.  So, I took to a redesign of the original and below is the result. Hull and basic dimensions aren't different but I have taken liberties.
Final Design - Redwing Classic Cruiser


Now that the design has reached its final iteration, I'll explain some of its finer points...
  • Mahogany brightwork frame and panel pilothouse and cabin over Marine AC Fir plywood.  My intention is to build them in panels and epoxy bond them to the plywood. A faux frame and panel so as not to invite water into the horizontal grooves. 
  • Interior white painted bead board ceiling and walls with mahogany cabinetry and trim.  
  • Full length canopy extends over cockpit for sun and rain protection.
  • Mahogany grab rails and hatches.
  • Enclosed motor well as in all of Ken's Redwing designs.
  • Pilot House bayed front windshield that extends over cabin top.
  • Drop down curtains to afford privacy for deck showers and bathroom breaks in cockpit.
  • Covered in Dynel or similar. All surfaces epoxy encapsulated.
Below...
  • V-Berth with 36" of headroom and louvered door.
  • A sink in the cockpit which is teak floored.
  • 9000BTU Marine Aire Heat Pump unit.
  • Dinette on Port side.
  • 3cuft Ice Box with 4" of poured insulation.
  • 62 gallons of fresh water storage.
  • 6 gallon electric water heater.
Lastly, the plans are still being fine tuned and you'll probably see some inconsistencies from view to view. I am working to finalize them before too long and will post those images later in the post so that there is a record of all the steps taken in the building of this vessel.
Thanks,
Mike


 
 

Why am I building a boat?

I have always wanted to build a boat. I mean a real boat...
I have toyed with this in one capacity or another over the years. I am a middle age man in a relatively landlocked part of the state I live, but thankfully not too far to reach the ocean within 5 to 6 hours' drive (not that I ever get there other than business). I am married to a woman that has worked side by side with me in the early years of our partnership doing some pretty physically challenging work. We've  built barns, remodeled spaces, landscaped and generally did whatever was necessary to survive.  As need finally dictated, I found more traditional employment as a  CAD drafter, eventually working my way up to an engineer position for a major electric utility in a very specialized design department.  We didn't stop our work together though. As we acquired tools and space to use them, we continued to  increase our skill set by building furniture, cabinets and other casework . We enjoyed nice furniture and could never afford to buy it so we tried our best and we endeavored to build it.  This was and is the driving force of all the things we have built together. We like beautiful, well made things and can only have it if we eliminate the labor portion of that expense by doing it ourselves. 

My personal projects were, and still are to some degree, dictated by money or the relative scarcity of it. No real surprise there to many reading this. In many ways that is the eternal rub isn't it?  Unless we are lucky enough to be born wealthy, money is the limiting factor in our youth with time in abundance, and time becomes the rare commodity as we grow older. I limited the scope of what I could accomplish based on what I could afford. Sometimes (my wife says "all the time") ignoring the "afford" part of that dictum. I have built or rebuilt a few boats, a strip canoe according to Ted Moore's Canoecraft and moving up a notch many years ago, a non descript 16' powerboat rebuild from the keelson up (sold as soon as was finished and never launched to finance the down payment on my first home).  Great learning experiences but not quite what I dreamed of.  We own a 17' Mako Pro Skiff (or in partnerships with my bank to be more precise) for several years and it serves nicely as a fishing boat.  No camping or cruising to be done out of it but that is not what it was designed for. So, I started thinking...
Cedar Strip Prospector Canoe
I spent my youth being exposed to this maritime passion in one degree or another. The "it", the deep vein of recurring interest in things nautical, has bubbled up over the years.   Walking around the marinas in Tampa with my Father as a 6 year old boy, looking at boats he couldn't afford as a young father, is a deeply poignant, stirring memory. Maybe it is the sea and the draw it has always had on people that places these memories at what seems a genetic level. Whatever it is, this instinctive cellular memory will, for a flash of brilliant clarity, transport me to an age and feeling that makes childhood the limitless world we adults envy. When retrieved and meditated on, it and other countless memories along the Gulf Coast of my youth contribute to the reasons that drive me toward the project that I endeavor to record here. Pouring through books on fish and marine life as a boy in our Tampa living room, playing in the breakwaters at Bradenton Beach, looking out of the window as we traversed the Florida landscape which seemed to me an endless jungle of adventure and excitement are rooted deep in me and seemed to have flooded back in recent years as I have grown older and care less about the posturing and approval of young adulthood. 
 
This, I believe, is the real reason why I am driven to build this boat and why I chose this design.  It isn't an exercise in plywood and fiberglass.  I am not building it to prove something to myself. The nuts and bolts of this don't signify.  For me, this vessel, this means of conveyance is the realization of a lifelong desire for adventure.  It can be poked up creeks and skinny water but still carry two for a week or more of comfortable cruising. At least the comfort level we can endure.  Exploring the coastline of the southeast with my wife, sharing with her what I have experienced but moreover, creating new experiences that neither of us have yet to share is why I am building this boat. Taking friends and family, a new Granddaughter (another on the way) on day cruises in style while we beach on some remote strand for a picnic is why I am building this boat. And to take my Dad out for some of that unrealized adventure sacrificed to raise a family is why I am building this boat.